Fire Hazard
Where there’s smoke, there’s pollution. How can airport firefighters green it up?
- By Sam Goldberg
- Air & Space magazine, July 2009
A fire at Boston Logan International was started with Tekflame, but looks like — and acts like — conflagration of Jet A.
FF/EMT Lisa Buchanan, Massport Fire-Rescue Department
For most airport firefighters, the gritty, grueling kind of work—the kind they love—comes just once a year, courtesy of the Federal Aviation Administration. On those days, firefighters can ditch the weight training schedule, shrug off a zillion disaster management PowerPoints, and get to the good stuff: turning an actual hose against an actual flame.
The FAA requires all airport firefighters to train in at least one “live fire” exercise every 12 months. But even those rare training days have been affected by environmental regulations. Government agencies at all levels have ordered live-fire training facilities to be retrofitted—or torn down and constructed anew—with filters to keep both the fuels that produce practice fires and the agents that extinguish them from leeching into the ground.
Fire departments have replaced Halon, a favorite firefighting agent but an ozone-eating monster, with a more ecologically friendly foam called Halotron. And cheap, smoky fossil fuels like Jet A, widely burned in live-fire practice pits, are being dumped for less polluting alternatives—one in particular. Liquid propane is frequently substituted for jet fuel because it’s cheap and burns without emitting pollutants. Still, most firefighters don’t care for it.
“It lacks the realism,” says Master Sergeant Kevin Matlock, fire chief at Washington state’s McChord Air Force Base, where he trains enlistees. “We’ve got a lot of young firefighters who don’t know how hydrocarbon fuels react, that don’t know that the fire will burn back on you,” he explains.
Unlike jet fuel, propane smokes only if it is burned too lean (with too little oxygen) or too rich. Because it combusts at a much lower temperature than a complex hydrocarbon fuel, it throws off much less heat. Propane fires also burn less chaotically than jet fuel blazes.
“Jet fuel is really unique because it rolls and has fireballs—it’s almost got a mind of its own,” says Bill Hutfilz, the training officer for Clark County Fire Department at Las Vegas McCarran International Airport and vice chairman of an airport firefighters’ group devoted to industry education. “Propane doesn’t. Hydrocarbon burns a lot blacker and it runs and hides. It’s going to get in the cracks in the airplane or cracks in the concrete. Wherever that fuel is, that fire is going to follow.”
Despite the trend toward propane, many FAA-approved firefighter training facilities still burn fossil fuels. But a few have managed to strike a balance between environmental stewardship and the realism of jet fuel without turning to propane. The regional facility at Boston Logan International is among them.
In 2005, Paul Callinan, the airport’s assistant chief for training, oversaw his department’s shift to Tekflame, a hydrocarbon that has been scrubbed of an additive that makes jet fuel burn evenly. The additive, Benzene, also causes much of the smoke that comes from burning fuel.
“I feel that our facility, using Tekflame as the fuel, gives a far more realistic attitude and environment than it would by using propane,” says Callinan. But, he adds, “it’s very, very expensive—double the cost, if not more, of regular fuel. Eight dollars a gallon, compared to the $2.90 a gallon we used to pay for jet fuel.”
Comments (4)
Great artical. As a retired Air Force Fire Chief I can tell you that realistic training is a most desirable option. I have used propain and other fuels but you can not replace the real thing. Training is the key to any operation that simulates the real "thing".
Posted by Charles Richardson on May 23,2009 | 08:47 PM
Airport firefighters should be trained on situations that are likely to occur, not with "green friendly" scenerios. Entering dimly lit smoke filled cabins via a ladder to search for people is not likely to be a anticapated event. Aircraft fires are most likely to involve an aircraft having an accident on takeoff or landing resulting in a large fireball fueled by large quanities of jet fuel. In this time passenger life spans are measured in seconds.
Posted by jerry denton on June 4,2009 | 04:53 PM
Questtion for Chief Richardson.
Can you tell me anything about the Army Engineer Aviation Fire Fighting units on Iwo Jima from shortly after the invasion until the end of WW II?
Thank you.
James G. Davis, Member and Historian
1204th Army Engineer Fire Fighting Platoon
North Africa - Italy - France - Germany
World War II
Posted by James G. Davis on June 8,2009 | 01:11 AM
For James G. Davis. Sorry dave but my career started in 1962. DoDfire.com has a history of the fire service but I'm not sure if there is anything about the units on Iwo Jima at that time.
Posted by Charles Richardson on June 13,2009 | 07:43 PM
I beg to differ with Mr. Denton. I was a firefighter at Sea-Tac airport for a little over 30 years and was a professional firefighter for 39 years retiring in 2006 just a few months before the dept. acquired the mockup. I was a shift commander for over 20 years and the initial officer in charge of the Horizon crash. I would have loved to have the mockup for training while I was there. A big crash is a "do whatever you can" type incident. It is next to impossible to train for that. The value with the mock up is in training the ff's to reduce or eliminate needless damage from smaller incidents such as smoke filled cockpits and cabins due to electrical fires or other small fires or smokey situations. Opening doors and assisting in evacuation are valuable training scenarios that many airport fire departments do not get an opportunity to practice on. The training provided for the firefighters at Sea-Tac Airport is some of the best in the world and the training staff has worked very hard to accomplish such a high level. I was very proud to retire from such a fine Department and I know that the officers and firefighters there are some of the best trained ARFF firefighters around. Don Couture
Posted by Don Couture on August 12,2009 | 07:30 PM