• About Air & Space
  • Email Updates
  • Member Services
  • Shop
  • Archive
airspacemag.com
  • Smithsonian Institution
  • Smithsonian Channel
  • goSmithsonian
  • Smithsonian magazine
  • Home
  • History of Flight
  • Flight Today
  • Military Aviation
  • Space Exploration
  • Photos & Videos
  • Subscribe
The F/A-22 Raptor performs aerial maneuvers during the Aviation Nation airshow on Nellis Air Force Base in November 2007. The F/A-22 Raptor performs aerial maneuvers during the Aviation Nation airshow on Nellis Air Force Base in November 2007.
(U.S Air Force Airman Stephanie Rubi)
  • Military Aviation

Birth of the Kulbit

Not just maneuverability. Supermaneuverability.

  • By Roger Mola
  • airspacemag.com, May 21, 2008

Article Tools

 
  • Font
  • Share/Save/Bookmark Share
     
  • Email
  •  
  • Print
  • Digg Digg
     
  • Comments
  • StumbleUpon StumbleUpon
     
  • RSS
  • Reddit Reddit
     

    How Things Work: Thrust Vectoring

    Jim Mathews

    In a tight spot, you need zoom to maneuver.

    The Raptor Rocks

    Linda Shiner

    F-22s treat airshow fans to a maneuverability demo.

    Most Popular

    • Viewed
    • Emailed
    1. Welcome to Cyberairspace
    2. B-36: Bomber at the Crossroads
    3. Fear of Floating
    4. Live and Let Fly
    5. The Notorious Flight of Mathias Rust
    6. The Dawn of Discipline
    7. Voices from the Moon
    8. Can We Stop a Nuke?
    9. Red, White, and Blue
    10. Above and Beyond: My Enemy, My Friend
    1. Above and Beyond: My Enemy, My Friend
    2. Apollo’s Army
    3. Aviation's Jackie Robinson
    4. B-36: Bomber at the Crossroads
    5. Above & Beyond: Shooting Up a Shooting Star
    6. Torture Chamber
    7. Flameout
    8. Exit Strategy
    9. Fear of Floating
    10. Can We Stop a Nuke?

    The idea of thrust vectoring dates to the early 1980s, when Wolfgang Herbst of the German aerospace group Messerschmitt-Bölkow-Blohm (MBB) envisioned a new class of aircraft that could maintain complete control while flying at airspeeds and angles of attack that would stall most aircraft. Such “post-stall maneuvers” could, in theory, be achieved with raw thrust alone when the airplane no longer had lift to fly in the conventional sense.

    Normally, even the best-designed wings can stall at angles of attack above 20 degrees because normal control surfaces lose their effectiveness. The ability to rear up like a cobra in mid-flight would offer a huge tactical advantage to a fighter aircraft, predicted William Siuru in a paper published in 1988 by Airpower Journal.

    “Let us look at an engagement between two fighters, one with post-stall maneuvering capability and one without it," he wrote. "The supermaneuverable fighter could turn much faster and dissipate much less energy in the process. Quite conceivably, it would have the adversary in its weapon system field of view several critical seconds before the other has completed its turn and is in firing position.”

    Siuru warned that state-of-the-art Soviet fighters such as the Sukhoi Su-27 Flanker, the MiG-29 Fulcrum, and the MiG-31 Foxhound were nearing the capability of the U.S. fleet. “To give our pilots the edge, new designs incorporating advanced technologies are needed as well as revised tactics to get the most out of the improvements,” he suggested. “Enhanced maneuvering is high on the list.”

    Early research for U.S. fighters centered on the Rockwell-MBB X-31 enhanced fighter maneuverability (EFM) program at NASA’s Dryden Flight Research Center in California. The first flight came in April, 1992. Within a year, the X-31 could fly a 180-degree turn in the minimum radius, a trick well beyond the aerodynamic limits of a conventional aircraft. The maneuver was called the Herbst, to honor the German scientist. The X-31 was soon joined at NASA Dryden by an F-18 and an F-16, which continued research on thrust vectoring in more than one axis.

    In the U.S., research focused on rectangular, two-dimensional nozzles, such as those adopted for the Pratt & Whitney F-119 engine in the Lockheed Martin F-22 Raptor, while designers in Russia used a circular nozzle for the Su-37.

    Thrust vectoring may someday give pilots the edge in actual dogfights, but in the meantime the technology has become a top crowd-pleaser at airshows. One move possible only with thrust vectoring is the Kulbit, a somersault performed with the airplane at a full stall, and executed in the smallest possible forward and vertical distance. Russian pilots introduced it, but today every self-respecting thrust-vectoring airplane, including the MiG-29, the Sukhoi 30MK, and, of course, the Raptor has incorporated the sequence into its routine. When it comes to wowing the audience these days, "supermaneuverability" is all but required.

    The idea of thrust vectoring dates to the early 1980s, when Wolfgang Herbst of the German aerospace group Messerschmitt-Bölkow-Blohm (MBB) envisioned a new class of aircraft that could maintain complete control while flying at airspeeds and angles of attack that would stall most aircraft. Such “post-stall maneuvers” could, in theory, be achieved with raw thrust alone when the airplane no longer had lift to fly in the conventional sense.

    Normally, even the best-designed wings can stall at angles of attack above 20 degrees because normal control surfaces lose their effectiveness. The ability to rear up like a cobra in mid-flight would offer a huge tactical advantage to a fighter aircraft, predicted William Siuru in a paper published in 1988 by Airpower Journal.

    “Let us look at an engagement between two fighters, one with post-stall maneuvering capability and one without it," he wrote. "The supermaneuverable fighter could turn much faster and dissipate much less energy in the process. Quite conceivably, it would have the adversary in its weapon system field of view several critical seconds before the other has completed its turn and is in firing position.”

    Siuru warned that state-of-the-art Soviet fighters such as the Sukhoi Su-27 Flanker, the MiG-29 Fulcrum, and the MiG-31 Foxhound were nearing the capability of the U.S. fleet. “To give our pilots the edge, new designs incorporating advanced technologies are needed as well as revised tactics to get the most out of the improvements,” he suggested. “Enhanced maneuvering is high on the list.”

    Early research for U.S. fighters centered on the Rockwell-MBB X-31 enhanced fighter maneuverability (EFM) program at NASA’s Dryden Flight Research Center in California. The first flight came in April, 1992. Within a year, the X-31 could fly a 180-degree turn in the minimum radius, a trick well beyond the aerodynamic limits of a conventional aircraft. The maneuver was called the Herbst, to honor the German scientist. The X-31 was soon joined at NASA Dryden by an F-18 and an F-16, which continued research on thrust vectoring in more than one axis.

    In the U.S., research focused on rectangular, two-dimensional nozzles, such as those adopted for the Pratt & Whitney F-119 engine in the Lockheed Martin F-22 Raptor, while designers in Russia used a circular nozzle for the Su-37.

    Thrust vectoring may someday give pilots the edge in actual dogfights, but in the meantime the technology has become a top crowd-pleaser at airshows. One move possible only with thrust vectoring is the Kulbit, a somersault performed with the airplane at a full stall, and executed in the smallest possible forward and vertical distance. Russian pilots introduced it, but today every self-respecting thrust-vectoring airplane, including the MiG-29, the Sukhoi 30MK, and, of course, the Raptor has incorporated the sequence into its routine. When it comes to wowing the audience these days, "supermaneuverability" is all but required.


     
    Comments

    does this mean that the eurofighter is not a new generation aircraft

    Posted by kev on May 29,2008 | 05:57AM

    This article got the basic idea, but there were too many errors: 1- Wing stall is not caused by "normal control surfaces lose their effectiveness". Stall is caused by the wing losing its ability to generate lift when the airflow over the wing breaks down and separates. The loss of control effectivness is a by-product of the wing stall. 2- The MiG-31 is not a maneuverable aircraft. 3- The MiG-29 is not equipped with thrust vectoring. A final note: The advent of highly manueverable air-to-air missiles, with off-boresight capability coupled with helmet-mounted cueing systems, has greatly reduced the need for super maneuverable fighters to bring their opponents first in their weapon system field of view.

    Posted by Sami Mina on May 29,2008 | 06:13PM

    Re: comment by Mina Yes, but highly manueverable missiles just aren't the crowd pleasers that highly manueverable airplanes are.

    Posted by Mike Rodrian on June 2,2008 | 09:34PM

    Almost all 4+ generation fighters can theoreticaly be equip with thrust vectoring engine and thus can theoreticaly perform Kulbit. Like Sami Mina said, the next evolution in maneuvarability will be on the missile design and the accompanying HMS. There's actually no technological limit to the level of maneuvarability an aicraft design can achieve. the limit lies on the human pilot. human body can only tolerate around 7 to 9Gs on average. MIG-31 are pure high-speed interceptor with impressive Mach 3 high altitude speed. it's a formidable missile platform able to launch it's missile a very long range. But the trade-off is that it has very poor dogfighting capability just like it's predessor MIG-25.

    Posted by Fadly Abdul Rahman on July 14,2008 | 11:03PM

    MIG-31 has a top speed of 2.83 Mach at high altitude.

    Posted by Chris on November 5,2008 | 08:25AM

    Post a Comment


    Name: (required)

    Email: (required)

    Comment:



    Advertisement

    Air & Space Videos

    Wright B Over Manhattan, 1912

    In the winter of 1912, Frank Coffyn filmed the first silent motion pictures of New York ever taken from an airplane.

    A Space Suit Ahead of Its Time

    More flexible than the Apollo suit, the EX-1A never flew.

    Marines Test the Joint Strike Fighter

    A Marine takes the new F-35 for a spin.

    On the Prowl

    On the Prowl

    Climb into the cockpit for a flight in an EA-6B Prowler.

    The Human Price

    Apollo veteran Lynn Radcliffe recalls the constant stress and long hours.

    Mercury Astronauts Meet the Press, 1959

    ...and answer the question: "What was your least favorite test?"

    Advertisement

    Marketplace

    SmithsonianStore

    Night at the Museum Adult Collage Tee
    Item no: 28206

    Window Shopping

    Gifts, Gadgets and Great Finds!

    Travel & Adventure

    A Family Weekend in Washington, D.C.: Featuring "Night at the Museum: Battle of the Smithsonian"

    Spend a fun-filled weekend with your family discovering the magic of the new feature film, "Night at the Museum: Battle of the Smithsonian" (Jul. 24 - 26, 2009)

    In the Magazine

    July 2009

    • Step Outside
    • Where the Wild Things Are
    • The Six
    • Travels with Churchill
    • Tumbling with the Stars
    • The Billy Mitchell Court-Martial
    • Fire Hazard

    View Table of Contents

    Snapshot

    Max Abort

    We hope it'll never be more than a test.

    Reader Scrapbook

    Send In Your Photos

    Check out our scrapbook of readers' aviation and space pictures. Then add your own.

    Need to Know

    What determines an airplane’s lifespan?

    Some keep flying for decades, while others end up on the scrap heap.

    Smithsonian Journeys

    Moorish Treasures of the Mediterranean

    Follow the ancient trade route and discover the civilizations that flourished in its wake



    View full archiveRecent Issues


    • Jul 2009


    • May 2009


    • Mar 2009

    Newsletter

    Sign up for regular email updates from Air & Space magazine, including free newsletters, special offers and current news updates.

    Subscribe Now

    About Us

    Air & Space/Smithsonian magazine has been delighting aerospace enthusiasts with the best writing about their favorite subject since April 1986. As an adjunct of the Smithsonian Institution's National Air and Space Museum, Air & Space matches the grand scope of the Museum, encompassing every era of aviation and space exploration. With stories that range from the Wright Brothers to the design of NASA's next lunar lander, Air & Space emphasizes the human stories as well as the technology of aviation and spaceflight.

    Explore our Brands

    • goSmithsonian.com
    • Smithsonian Air & Space Museum
    • Smithsonian Institution
    • Smithsonian Catalogue
    • Smithsonian Journeys
    • Smithsonian Channel
    • Site Map
    • Privacy Policy
    • Copyright
    • About Air & Space
    • Contact Us
    • Advertising
    • Reader Panel
    • Subscribe
    • RSS

    Smithsonian Institution

    Produced by Clickability